What if Sayid HAD killed Henry?

[The_abbott]

Originally Posted by KoRevo,October 12, 2006 04:30 pm

In actual fact it wouldve been interesting to see Sayids reaction had he killed Henry..because it would be useful to contrast his response to Charlie's, when he murdered Ethan under not too disimilar circumstances.. I do suspect that Sayid wouldve regretted it..so perhaps this owuldve told us alot about Charlie also..considering he hardly battered an eyelid after his massacre of Ethan. And to think all hell broke loose when Ana put 6 bullets into Jason..how we forget Charlie's 6 bullet massacre of Ethan.. Jason afterall hasnt been missed

Maybe Jason was Henrys son or something. Henry did not particularly like Ana did he

[Nickeshi]

That was probably becuase of when Goodwin jumped onto that stick Ana was holding, and he blamed Ana for it.

[The_abbott]

Originally Posted by Nickeshi,October 13, 2006 08:40 am

That was probably becuase of when Goodwin jumped onto that stick Ana was holding, and he blamed Ana for it.

I thought that but he said "you killed one of us" but so has Charlie and Eko but no mention to them. Maybe theres more too it

[Nickeshi]

hmmmmmmmm good point, i wonder what they had against Ana specifically

[The_abbott]

Originally Posted by Nickeshi,October 13, 2006 09:51 am

hmmmmmmmm good point, i wonder what they had against Ana specifically

Henry only acted like it to her. It seems so strange. He wasn't that bad to Sayid who tortured him.

[Cherry Blossom Girl]

Hmmm... How do you suppose he would know that it was Ana who killed Goodwin?

I'm proabaly missing something obvious (did she tell him herself like Eko? I can't remember!), but does that in itself mean that the others are watching them more closely than we'd thought?

[St. Anger]

Did Ana let it slsip in conversation?

Would be well creepy if they are watching them all very closely undetected. Like during the ambush, they came out of nowhere in a big open field.

[Beach Crew]

I wish Sayid had killed Henry.

Ana and Libby would've been saved.

Sawyer wouldn't have been.... *Compses Self* kidnapped....

Things would've been good.

But then again...I can't help thinking, that if Sayid had killed Henry....the Other's would've sent somebody else, or planned an attack....

They seem pretty determinded, and that's what worries me.

[D-Roc]

Originally Posted by The_abbott,October 13, 2006 09:34 am

Maybe Jason was Henrys son or something. Henry did not particularly like Ana did he

He sure had issues with her..considering the brave lady saved his life and all! I mean whatever happened to 'paying it forward'? I suspect that Goodwin was a particularly close friend of Henrys and he took except to the fact that she killed him. But like the guys have queried..how did HG know it was Ana who killed him? I guess they really are sneaky so and so's!

[D-Roc]

Originally Posted by The_abbott,October 13, 2006 10:47 am

I thought that but he said "you killed one of us" but so has Charlie and Eko but no mention to them. Maybe theres more too it

Good angle..there has to be more to it methinks..

But what?

Maybe it's the fact that Goodwin believed that she was worth saving and so in effect he was a martyr..because he died for his belief in her..(even though his death was his own stupid fault ). Now HG spoke about Martyrs to Jack and it seems as if this couldve infact been a reference to his beloved Goodwin. Perhaps the others dont like to be wrong?

[D-Roc]

Originally Posted by Beach Crew,October 14, 2006 12:33 pm

I wish Sayid had killed Henry.

Ana and Libby would've been saved.

Sawyer wouldn't have been.... *Compses Self* kidnapped....

Things would've been good.

But then again...I can't help thinking, that if Sayid had killed Henry....the Other's would've sent somebody else, or planned an attack....

They seem pretty determinded, and that's what worries me.

I must say B, i do worry for your Sawyer.. I mean, he and Zeke have unfinished business and with Sawyer all gagged and bound i'd hate to think that Zeke might..shall we say..abuse his power Though Mr TreeFrog wont exactly be shedding any tears at the thought of Sawyer getting tortured, i guess

But then again, torture isnt exactly the others style is it..although im sure some might argue that keeping a man tied to a pole (Michael) for a few days is still torture

[St. Anger]

Anyone attend Mr Tree Frog's funeral?

Pretty sad occasion,.... turns out he was going to open up a fast-food chain on the island before his squishing!!

Mrs Tree Frog has vowed revenge on "...that damned Southern Sawyer".

[D-Roc]

lol

i think only Mrs Tree Frog and the Tree Frog Frog-lettes attended his funeral ..they also just put a downpayment on a swamp, apparently..

[St. Anger]

Originally Posted by KoRevo,October 15, 2006 09:15 am

lol

i think only Mrs Tree Frog and the Tree Frog Frog-lettes attended his funeral ..they also just put a downpayment on a swamp, apparently..

LOL, wait a sec, there aren't any swamps in LOST ! Well there is that lake kind of thing which had the dead bodies at the bottom in S1.

[-Jet-Stripes-]

Originally Posted by KoRevo,October 14, 2006 11:46 am

Good point but maybe this is another clue that Ethan is not dead. Which would therefore mean that Charlie did not kill one of "them". Not sure where this would leave Eko - are we sure that he killed those Others? I don't remember that episode too well I'm afraid.