If You Could Bring Any Other Back To Life?

[Audio Pineapple]

Originally Posted by Beach Crew

Colleen was funny - she was mean to Ben that one time, lol. And you leave Juliet alone!

But she was one of the least-rounded Others that we've had. Despite the horrendous Ms. Klugh of course!

I don't think she lived long enough to make an impression on me.


And I won't leave her alone!

[The_abbott]

Bonnie, she was a wee Bonnie lass.

Well probably not but we never really found anything out about them or why and when Ben sent them down there.

[Beach Crew]

Originally Posted by Audio Pineapple

But she was one of the least-rounded Others that we've had. Despite the horrendous Ms. Klugh of course!

I don't think she lived long enough to make an impression on me.


And I won't leave her alone!

If she hadn't of died I don't think Danny would've been so desperate to kill Sawyer like he was, and then Danny wouldn't of had to die. See. It's all Sun's fault!

I think it's coz she was amazing in ER.

But why? what has she done to make you hate her?

[Audio Pineapple]

Originally Posted by Kiowa Warrior

Yeah Ethan was great, and certainly didn't deserve to die unarmed and helpless at the hands of Charlie of all people! I think Ethan's probably had more screentime since he died than when he was alive, lol.

Even if he'd been killed by Jack I wouldn't have minded as much! At least Mikhail has finished the job Ethan couldn't!

I think he has done lol; shows what a mistake it was to get rid of him in the first place.

[Jen]

Tom!!!!

[Audio Pineapple]

Originally Posted by Beach Crew

If she hadn't of died I don't think Danny would've been so desperate to kill Sawyer like he was, and then Danny wouldn't of had to die. See. It's all Sun's fault!

I think it's coz she was amazing in ER.

But why? what has she done to make you hate her?

But how interesting would Danny have been without his rampant Sawyer-Hate? And I think with his loyalty to Ben he'd have gone after him regardless and then still been murdered by Juliet.

SHE TRIED TO KILL BEN! SHE DID KILL DANNY! (how could I not hate her character?!)

[Beach Crew]

Originally Posted by Audio Pineapple

But how interesting would Danny have been without his rampant Sawyer-Hate? And I think with his loyalty to Ben he'd have gone after him regardless and then still been murdered by Juliet.

SHE TRIED TO KILL BEN! SHE DID KILL DANNY! (how could I not hate her character?!)

I'm sure he would've been great! And it would've spared me a heart-attack. I don't know, I think he would've been nicer, lol.

Well what is wrong with that - he was trying to kill Sawyer! She's a wonderful person!

[Kiowa Warrior]

Originally Posted by Audio Pineapple

Even if he'd been killed by Jack I wouldn't have minded as much! At least Mikhail has finished the job Ethan couldn't!

I think he has done lol; shows what a mistake it was to get rid of him in the first place.

Yeah Ethan deserved to die fighting, rather than have bloody Charlie sneak along, steal a gun and shoot him several times! But we have to remember Ethan's good times though, such as nearly getting rid of Charlie and giving Jack a thorough and well deserved beating in the rain. We miss you Ethan

As much as I wanted Charlie gone his death was the saddest one yet for me...but I still can't be mad at Mikhail for it, since Mikhail is great and Charlie is not!

[Audio Pineapple]

Ben wasn't trying to kill Sawyer though and the worst part of it all was that she didn't even have the stones to do it herself! She tried to puppy-dog-eye Jack into making a 'mistake.'

[Audio Pineapple]

Originally Posted by Kiowa Warrior

Yeah Ethan deserved to die fighting, rather than have bloody Charlie sneak along, steal a gun and shoot him several times! But we have to remember Ethan's good times though, such as nearly getting rid of Charlie and giving Jack a thorough and well deserved beating in the rain. We miss you Ethan

As much as I wanted Charlie gone his death was the saddest one yet for me...but I still can't be mad at Mikhail for it, since Mikhail is great and Charlie is not!

Ahh Ethan has had lots of good times!

Sadder than Boone's slow and painful demise and his "tell Shannon?" Nah, Boone wins it for me as the saddest death. Then possibly Libby just for the fact that all she wanted were some blankets, but it might not be her, I can't decide lol.

[b-r-a-d]

Originally Posted by The_abbott

Bonnie, she was a wee Bonnie lass.

Well probably not but we never really found anything out about them or why and when Ben sent them down there.

oooh i forgot about Bonnie and Greta i would bring them back!

[Mrs Ferg]

the girls in the under water station (was that Bonnie?) because they would have had such a good story to tell, how did they get there? why did ben kept it a secret.

[Mrs Ferg]

sorry abbs didnt relise you had posted almost the same thing

[Kiowa Warrior]

Originally Posted by Audio Pineapple

Ahh Ethan has had lots of good times!

Sadder than Boone's slow and painful demise and his "tell Shannon?" Nah, Boone wins it for me as the saddest death. Then possibly Libby just for the fact that all she wanted were some blankets, but it might not be her, I can't decide lol.

He really did! He represents what the Others are all about: people that seem evil on the outside, but are really just misunderstood that have to do work they may not like for the greater good!

Yeah for me it was, because I got spoiled about Boone's death very early on in S1 and when it was actually shown on tv the mood was broken every ten minutes by those bloody awful 118 adverts! Ana and Libby's deaths were great shocks for me because I didn't know about them but not really sad, because I didn't really like either of their characters. Whereas I really didn't think Charlie would actually die, and although he's not one of my favourite characters at all he had been with us from the start so it was sad to see an orginal cast member get killed off.