To Put A Spanner In The Works

[daviePOSEIDON]

This discussion has died down a lot recently. Who is Jack's half sister. Many think it's Claire, others think it's Kate. I just thought...what about...Juliette!

[Blloydy]

That's a possibility. It's always interesting to think about this. I hope it isn't Kate anyway - I think Jack and Kate would be nice together, But Kate and Sawyer are too - I just can't decide.

Maybe we will find out more about Juliette in future episodes which reveal more, and show us if she is his sister. She did have that big file of Jack's life, would that mean she knows? (if they are half siblings that is)

She did seem quite protective of him. Bringing him food, ect. Althought that may have been so that he would side with her to sabotage Ben's operation.

I think that, if it is Juliette, which is possible - knowing Lost and many of the people are usually connected in some way - it will be very interesting to see how he reacts to this. Does he even know that he has a half sister? And Ana is dead, so she can't tell him.

[James]

Its possible but his half sister is more likely to be Australain as thats where Christian went to find her and Juliet isnt Australian. Also when Christian went to the house with Ana to find his daughter Christian must of known that his daughter was in Australia at the time and seems unlikely that Juliet would have been Australia a week before the plane crashed as she seemed quite cosy on the Island when we saw the plane crash from the others perspective.

[Losty]

I'm totally convinced it's Claire, but the theory of Juliet is interesting.

[Toby]

Claire, has to be :P Juliete... would be a lot more interesting though!

Ah, but what if Jack was the father of arron?

[Blloydy]

Originally Posted by Toby,January 20, 2007 10:01 pm

Claire, has to be :P Juliete... would be a lot more interesting though!

Ah, but what if Jack was the father of arron?

Don't you think he'd recognise Claire? :P It would be really cool though

[b-r-a-d]

I think ist claire! She needs a storyline somehow!

[Cavegirl]

Originally Posted by b-r-a-d,January 20, 2007 09:33 pm

I think ist claire! She needs a storyline somehow!

Excellent answer! Poor Claire, when are they going to give her something to do? Arron needs to get kidnapped so she can get a life.

I think it would be a good twist if it was Kate, although they have set it up so it could be either of those 2. Juliette hadn't occurred to me. I think she's a too old to be hiding out at her Mum's house? Maybe they will tell us in a big reveal at the end of this series.

[St. Anger]

Originally Posted by James,January 20, 2007 01:16 pm

Its possible but his half sister is more likely to be Australain as thats where Christian went to find her and Juliet isnt Australian. Also when Christian went to the house with Ana to find his daughter Christian must of known that his daughter was in Australia at the time and seems unlikely that Juliet would have been Australia a week before the plane crashed as she seemed quite cosy on the Island when we saw the plane crash from the others perspective.

This is true. It can't be Julliete.

It must be Claire, or possibly Claire's sister [if she has one].

Then again, why would Christian have waited 20-odd years [depending on Claire's age] to want to see her? Surely he would've done so many many years ago when Claire was a little baby or kid. Though maybe he did, if so, why bother trying again if he was rejected the first time by the woman at the front door?

I swear Nikki sounds Australian sometimes... Could she be Jacko's sister,...hence a way to give her a more meaningful role. Though whoever it is, we must consider how such a revelation would take place. I mean, surely if anyone is to make such a revelation it will be the Others as they've databases on the Losties.

[E Pluribus Unum]

Originally Posted by St. Anger (o'_'o),January 21, 2007 12:17 pm

This is true. It can't be Julliete.

It must be Claire, or possibly Claire's sister [if she has one].

Then again, why would Christian have waited 20-odd years [depending on Claire's age] to want to see her? Surely he would've done so many many years ago when Claire was a little baby or kid. Though maybe he did, if so, why bother trying again if he was rejected the first time by the woman at the front door?

It happens, just watch the Jerry Springer show!

And if I was turned away from seeing my son or daughter, I certainly wouldn't just give up and walk away, never to try again...

[Laura~J]

I'd go for Claire, no question.

How can it be Kate? We've all seen Kate's mum and it wasn't the same woman as the one Christian went to see.

[E Pluribus Unum]

Originally Posted by Laura~J,January 21, 2007 12:26 pm

I'd go for Claire, no question.

How can it be Kate? We've all seen Kate's mum and it wasn't the same woman as the one Christian went to see.

You're presuming that was the mum, of course

[Laura~J]

Well I like to think so :P

[E Pluribus Unum]

Originally Posted by Laura~J,January 21, 2007 12:35 pm

Well I like to think so :P

I do wonder if perhaps the woman at the door was Sarah's (Jacks ex) sister. It would make sense that he would try and talk to Sarah, maybe to get her to take Jack back - as some kind way for Chris to win Jack back - to prove he wasn't useless...

The whole 'I wanna see my daughter' - technically she was his daughter in-law and he was drunk, so maybe...

The woman at the door and Sarah are extremely similar - probably just coincidence though...maybe