Death Count

[Matt Gogi]

Originally Posted by firebreathingfishies

Especially seeing as the plane was practically held up by a couple of leaves and twigs

Exactly, what was Locke thinking

[esn]

So if Locke told Boone to go and jump of a cliff, would Boone have done that?

actually... yeah fair point



But seriosuly, IMO Boone could have just said no, I mean Locke was in no position to stop him

[firebreathingfishies]

Yeah but... it was Boone

He would have got off with his sister if she told him too... oh, hang on

[esn]

Originally Posted by firebreathingfishies

Yeah but... it was Boone

He would have got off with his sister if she told him too... oh, hang on

Although she wasn't actually his sister

Sorry but "he told me to do it" has never been a defence for ones actions and "he told him to do it" shouldnt be a case for murder/killing somone.

but it is Abbs thread, so he can decide

[firebreathingfishies]

But Locke's excuse for everything has been 'The Island told me to'

He killed Naomi because Taller Ghost Walt told him to

[-x-madegurl-x-]

locke's responsible. end of.

but i wouldn't call charlie responsible for mikhail. that was ben's fault more likely because didnt he send him down there?
charlie never did anythig to make mikhail set off that grenade.

[The_abbott]

But also remember Locke lied to Jack about Boones injury. Had he told the truth Jack may of saved Boone.

[esn]

Originally Posted by firebreathingfishies

But Locke's excuse for everything has been 'The Island told me to'

He killed Naomi because Taller Ghost Walt told him to

But that doesnt make it the islands fault - or giant Walts fault. That makes it his fault and his alone.

Although Boone was unfortunate, but if he just turned round to Locke, and said "like feck Am I going up there, go up there yo self" He'd still be alive, regardless of what Locke said or did

[The_abbott]

Originally Posted by esn

Although she wasn't actually his sister

and amen to that. Shannon was no fool

[esn]

Originally Posted by The_abbott

But also remember Locke lied to Jack about Boones injury. Had he told the truth Jack may of saved Boone.

True - I had forgotten about that. It is debatable though, if Boone was beyhond repair anyways.

wheres Roco and Ki when you bloody well need them

[Beach Crew]

Originally Posted by The_abbott

But also remember Locke lied to Jack about Boones injury. Had he told the truth Jack may of saved Boone.

Thank. You.

So many people seem to miss out this little fact. He lied to Jack and then just ran off to cry about how he wasn't getting his own way. He was crying, not for Boone, but because the island wasn't letting him do what he wanted!

Boone might have survived, and Boone should never have gone up the tree in the first place. I still stand by the fact that Locke is responsible for Boone's death.

[Him]

Jae and Boone are adults responsible for themselves. Saying Sun and Locke, respectively, killed them, is just absurd. It compromises what could be a useful thread.

[TheDharmaShark]

Did Locke tell Jack Boone fell off a cliff? If so, whats the difference? In both cases its still injuries as a result of a bad fall. Pinning Boone's death on Locke is just one of many attempts to bring the man down. It was Boone's choice to go up to the plane, like Him said he's an adult responsible for his own decisions. It was Boone's eagerness to help out that killed him, not Locke.