Your favourite Freighter person??

[Lost Lewis]

Daniel, definitely! He's hilarious and not at all like the others. Frank seems good as well. Charlotte's scary looking and Miles is...angry. I have a lot of jumbled up thoughts on the lot of them really!

Originally Posted by D-Roc

And I have to give a shout-out to the seriously hot Naomi. Why did she have to die?

...?

[lost-lover]

I have to go for Daniel, that guy is brilliant and hilarious! And hot! Miles makes me laugh too, he's probably my second favourite form the freighter because he's, to use Hurley's phrase, the ship's answer to Sawyer

[*SP*]

Poor Frank

I really like him and didn't just give him a sympathy vote...he's genuinely my favourite out of the four. As has been said previously, he reminds me of Locke in a way with his voice and mannerisms. I'm so intrigued because he was supposed to be the pilot of 815. He's just appealing in some way and I'm drawn to him. I am concerned though that he could be the first one to be killed off.

I really can't stand Miles at all. I find him annoying beyond belief, extremely brash and a wholly unsympathetic character. Yeah, he has an interesting storyline, I'm probably most interested in finding out his story over the other three but I don't like him personally.

I haven't warmed to Charlotte one little bit either. She's definitely my least favourite. She has done absolutely nothing to endear herself to me at all. The only thing noteworthy was the Polar Bear in the Desert thing but as a character she's exceptionally boring.

Daniel seems like a sweet guy and interesting. I agree his little comment about the way the light scatters should have been picked up on by Jack and Kate though it comes as no surprise that it went way over their heads. I'm not sure if I think he's got it in him to be a heavyweight character but I do like his mad scientist, bumbling gentleman type persona. He would take second place after Frank for sure. I don't know why I didn't write them in order of preference....

[Reed]

I loved Frank and Daniel in 4x03 - Frank comments in reply to the Red Sox comment from Jack had me in stitches - he just has a funny way about him. Daniel was as bumbling and quirky as ever, almost begging Frank to use the radio.

[D-Roc]

Originally Posted by Lost Lewis

...?

Yeah, I think she's quite smoking - perhaps Marsha Thomason looks better in real-life (if you will):

[Beach Crew]

Well, I don't really "like" any of them, or trust them, but I think Miles is fabulous!

He's so funny, and I love that he's so angry all the time. Like Hurley, I'm reminded of season one Sawyer, and so perhaps that's why I think he's a good character.

He makes me laugh too.

I can't stand Charlotte though, she really annoys me. I don't know why but she just....irritates me.

[Reed]

In light of current events I would have to say Miles moves up my list, even though I have always liked him.

I loved the duo with Sawyer in 4x10.

[lost-lover]

Have to agree Reed, those two together are a great double act.

[Reed]

They were indeed, though I do not think Miles is phased by Sawyer's threats. I loved the way he sarcastically said "I gotcha" or something like that. Very amusing stuff.

[lost-lover]

Sawyer: I'll put my boot in your face unless you say I gotcha.
Miles: I gotcha.
Great stuff, and the whole restraining order thing was brilliant.

[Reed]

Ahh yes, very funny stuff. He did well to not appear intimidated by Sawyer with that line and the rolling of his eyes.

Though Miles loses points for letting Claire wander off and getting revenge on Sawyer.

[Miss Austen]

I found this a tough choice. I really like Daniel because he's a bit absent minded but sooo clever and I liked how he helped Desmond. But I voted for Miles because I think having someone on the island who can communicate with or read dead people's thoughts and emotions is a really fascinating plot device.

I thought it was weird that Miles was really interested in Claire just before she disappeared. Could Miles be seeing Christian Shepherd hovering close to Claire? (his daughter).

I also like Frank the Pilot and just long for he and Sawyer to have further encounters. I think they could be a good duo - especially after Sawyer called Frank: Kenny Rogers!!!!!