Desmond is saving Claire, not Charlie - Lost Community Forums - Official Spoiler-free Lost Fansite

hundredand8 · 03-22-2007, 01:00 PM

When Desmond first confesses to Charlie that he is saving him, not Claire this is a twist. The lightning would have hit Aaron, Claire and Charlie so we did not know. He then rescues Claire from the sea so its kinda obvious he is saving Claire. But then he says he was saving Charlie. I don't believe him.

Charlie wasn't near the net on the beech when Desmond fired the gun. He wasn't near the rocks where he found the bird, but Claire was there!

So I think he either thinks he is saving Charlie which means his visions are inaccurate. Or he is not telling the truth. Personaly I think its the latter, probably he believes that the situation is easier to manipulate if Claire feels safe for herself and Aaron, and Charlie is only worried about himself.

All speculation, but thats what I believe anyway.

***E Pluribus Unum*** · 03-22-2007, 01:05 PM

I think you're right. And let's not forget that Desmond said "Charlie.....you're going to die.......brutha"

he could hardly follow that up with, "Oh and the Aussie babe you've fallen for? She's in for it too, and her baby.....yup, that poor kid too."

It makes more sense this way, it does. Especially when we remember Des shooting to stop Claire, Sun and Jin from catching the bird...

I think at some point Des will have to choose between the two; who he saves. Haha, I think they should have a phone vote: "Who should Desmond save? You decide!"

I agree 108

~~**StoneRose**~~ · 03-22-2007, 01:56 PM

Maybe thats what Claires psychic saw aswell. Maybe he told her to board the plane not for her babys sake, but her own sake instead. Maybe she was first due to die in Oz, and by boarding the plane this extended her life a little longer.

Now maybe Des has taken over from the psycic in protecting Claire

hundredand8 · 03-22-2007, 01:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by StoneRose,March 22, 2007 10:56 am

Maybe thats what Claires psychic saw aswell. Maybe he told her to board the plane not for her babys sake, but her own sake instead. Maybe she was first due to die in Oz, and by boarding the plane this extended her life a little longer.

Now maybe Des has taken over from the psycic in protecting Claire

Thats genious!

~~**StoneRose**~~ · 03-22-2007, 02:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hundredand8,March 22, 2007 10:58 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by StoneRose,March 22, 2007 10:56 am

Maybe thats what Claires psychic saw aswell. Maybe he told her to board the plane not for her babys sake, but her own sake instead. Maybe she was first due to die in Oz, and by boarding the plane this extended her life a little longer.

Now maybe Des has taken over from the psycic in protecting Claire

Thats genious!

Why thank you

Losty · 03-22-2007, 05:40 PM

I hope to God you're right

But on the whole thing i'm

-x-madegurl-x- · 03-22-2007, 06:18 PM

It's obviously not going to be Charlie that he's saving because that would be such a simple storyline now, there's more to it and i think it might be right to think it's claire he's saving

Him · 03-22-2007, 06:41 PM

He's saving them all as they were all meant to die in their little... tent.
Makes perfect sense.

It's like final destination.

Lauren [is Lost] · 03-22-2007, 07:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hundredand8,March 22, 2007 10:00 am

When Desmond first confesses to Charlie that he is saving him, not Claire this is a twist. The lightning would have hit Aaron, Claire and Charlie so we did not know. He then rescues Claire from the sea so its kinda obvious he is saving Claire. But then he says he was saving Charlie. I don't believe him.

Charlie wasn't near the net on the beech when Desmond fired the gun. He wasn't near the rocks where he found the bird, but Claire was there!

So I think he either thinks he is saving Charlie which means his visions are inaccurate. Or he is not telling the truth. Personaly I think its the latter, probably he believes that the situation is easier to manipulate if Claire feels safe for herself and Aaron, and Charlie is only worried about himself.

All speculation, but thats what I believe anyway.

I wondered that you know. I think it's Claire he's actually saving - every time he has saved Charlie so far, Claire has been involved! Also i'm not convinced that Charlie is going to die because that would be too obvious now.
I'm thinking maybe Desmond has got it wrong.....in the sense that he thinks he is saving Charlie, but its actually Claire who needs saving.

Blloydy · 03-22-2007, 10:39 PM

I actually noticed this, it's not ever just Charlie that has been in a near death situation - it's been Claire.. If this all started straight after the sky turned purple, remember Claire almost being hit by the hatch 'quarantine' door? And if the universe really ment Charlie to die, wouldn't he have smashed into those rocks in the hippy van?

IM-LOST-WITH-LOST · 03-22-2007, 11:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lostie,March 22, 2007 07:39 pm

I actually noticed this, it's not ever just Charlie that has been in a near death situation - it's been Claire.. If this all started straight after the sky turned purple, remember Claire almost being hit by the hatch 'quarantine' door? And if the universe really ment Charlie to die, wouldn't he have smashed into those rocks in the hippy van?

I was about to say something about the qaurentine door, i was doing a sig earlier and was looking for Claire pics.... i came across one with bernard saving claire from the qaurentine door..... I really hope its not claire whos gonna die, i like claire better than charlie

Jen · 03-22-2007, 11:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lostie,March 22, 2007 08:39 pm

I actually noticed this, it's not ever just Charlie that has been in a near death situation - it's been Claire.. If this all started straight after the sky turned purple, remember Claire almost being hit by the hatch 'quarantine' door? And if the universe really ment Charlie to die, wouldn't he have smashed into those rocks in the hippy van?

maybe charlie didn't die in the hippy van thing ebcause hurley was there too? and Hurley wasn't supposed to die then?

and surely if Desmond was seeing Charlie dying he would have seen the whole van thing?

Blloydy · 03-22-2007, 11:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jenshtie,March 22, 2007 09:30 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lostie,March 22, 2007 08:39 pm

I actually noticed this, it's not ever just Charlie that has been in a near death situation - it's been Claire.. If this all started straight after the sky turned purple, remember Claire almost being hit by the hatch 'quarantine' door? And if the universe really ment Charlie to die, wouldn't he have smashed into those rocks in the hippy van?

maybe charlie didn't die in the hippy van thing ebcause hurley was there too? and Hurley wasn't supposed to die then?

Hmm yeah, good point. I though that Hurley was protected by the number curse, hence all the people around him die and not him. He survived crossing of the bridge and the Danni's trap ect. But the two curses could be linked.. If Charlie is 'supposed' to die, it could be because he is close to Hurley?

Quote:

and surely if Desmond was seeing Charlie dying he would have seen the whole van thing?

Yeah - so maybe it really is Claire who is supposed to die. Or maybe the hippy van was never a risk to Charlie's life in the first place, so Des never saw a vision about it..

Jen · 03-23-2007, 12:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lostie,March 22, 2007 09:50 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by jenshtie,March 22, 2007 09:30 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lostie,March 22, 2007 08:39 pm

I actually noticed this, it's not ever just Charlie that has been in a near death situation - it's been Claire.. If this all started straight after the sky turned purple, remember Claire almost being hit by the hatch 'quarantine' door? And if the universe really ment Charlie to die, wouldn't he have smashed into those rocks in the hippy van?

maybe charlie didn't die in the hippy van thing ebcause hurley was there too? and Hurley wasn't supposed to die then?

Hmm yeah, good point. I though that Hurley was protected by the number curse, hence all the people around him die and not him. He survived crossing of the bridge and the Danni's trap ect. But the two curses could be linked.. If Charlie is 'supposed' to die, it could be because he is close to Hurley?

Quote:

and surely if Desmond was seeing Charlie dying he would have seen the whole van thing?

Yeah - so maybe it really is Claire who is supposed to die. Or maybe the hippy van was never a risk to Charlie's life in the first place, so Des never saw a vision about it..

yeah it could be that hurley was protected,and maybe that because it was the same situation then teh curse had to protect Charlie too or something.

The_abbott · 03-23-2007, 12:41 AM

The only way I will except Charlie dying is if he dies protecting Claire and Aaron so excepting his fate.

If he dies catching a bird then thats just stupid and wasteful. I would stil rather Claire died......or Kate....or Paulo.

03-22-2007, 01:00 PM	#1 (permalink)
hundredand8 See you in another life Survivor Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 1,549	Desmond is saving Claire, not Charlie When Desmond first confesses to Charlie that he is saving him, not Claire this is a twist. The lightning would have hit Aaron, Claire and Charlie so we did not know. He then rescues Claire from the sea so its kinda obvious he is saving Claire. But then he says he was saving Charlie. I don't believe him. Charlie wasn't near the net on the beech when Desmond fired the gun. He wasn't near the rocks where he found the bird, but Claire was there! So I think he either thinks he is saving Charlie which means his visions are inaccurate. Or he is not telling the truth. Personaly I think its the latter, probably he believes that the situation is easier to manipulate if Claire feels safe for herself and Aaron, and Charlie is only worried about himself. All speculation, but thats what I believe anyway. __________________ Thanks to Matt Gogi for the lovely sig and to JB_Sawyer for making it a legal size

03-22-2007, 01:05 PM	#2 (permalink)
*E Pluribus Unum* Movie-Lover Island Guardian Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Twilight Zone Fave Character: Locke Lost Item: Rifle Posts: 3,451 Awards Showcase Total Awards: 5	Desmond is saving Claire, not Charlie I think you're right. And let's not forget that Desmond said "Charlie.....you're going to die.......brutha" he could hardly follow that up with, "Oh and the Aussie babe you've fallen for? She's in for it too, and her baby.....yup, that poor kid too." It makes more sense this way, it does. Especially when we remember Des shooting to stop Claire, Sun and Jin from catching the bird... I think at some point Des will have to choose between the two; who he saves. Haha, I think they should have a phone vote: "Who should Desmond save? You decide!" I agree 108 __________________ Recent Reviews: ~ The Dark Knight 5/5 *NEW* ~ Gone Baby Gone 5/5 ~ Indiana Jones and The Kingdom of the Crystal Skull 2.5/5 ~ Iron Man 4/5 ~ more Get REWARDED for posting movie REVIEWS and ARTICLES

03-22-2007, 01:56 PM	#3 (permalink)
~~StoneRose~~ I Am Banned Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 1,267	Desmond is saving Claire, not Charlie Maybe thats what Claires psychic saw aswell. Maybe he told her to board the plane not for her babys sake, but her own sake instead. Maybe she was first due to die in Oz, and by boarding the plane this extended her life a little longer. Now maybe Des has taken over from the psycic in protecting Claire

03-22-2007, 05:40 PM	#6 (permalink)
Losty Thorneless Rose Survivor Battle Pong Champion! Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: Behind you -_- Fave Character: Charlie Lost Item: Peanut Butter Posts: 3,533	Desmond is saving Claire, not Charlie I hope to God you're right But on the whole thing i'm __________________ Thank you FBF for the sig, and JB for the avi! *FanFiction.Net - AvatarBliss* Life can be MERDE.

03-22-2007, 06:18 PM	#7 (permalink)
-x-madegurl-x- Making Taco's for Kate Island Survivor Ultimate Pie Theft Champion! SpongeBob's Pizza Toss Champion! Tournaments Won: 1 Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Belper Fave Character: Boone Lost Item: Dharma Flakes Posts: 6,817 Awards Showcase Total Awards: 3	Desmond is saving Claire, not Charlie It's obviously not going to be Charlie that he's saving because that would be such a simple storyline now, there's more to it and i think it might be right to think it's claire he's saving __________________

03-22-2007, 06:41 PM	#8 (permalink)
Him Entering 77 Island Believer Asteroids Champion! Snake Champion! Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Glasvegas Fave Character: Locke Lost Item: Whiskey Posts: 7,715 Awards Showcase Total Awards: 6	Desmond is saving Claire, not Charlie He's saving them all as they were all meant to die in their little... tent. Makes perfect sense. It's like final destination. __________________ Copious amounts of animals were harmed in the making of this post.

03-22-2007, 10:39 PM	#10 (permalink)
Blloydy Island MSN Survivor Join Date: Sep 2006 Posts: 2,448	Desmond is saving Claire, not Charlie I actually noticed this, it's not ever just Charlie that has been in a near death situation - it's been Claire.. If this all started straight after the sky turned purple, remember Claire almost being hit by the hatch 'quarantine' door? And if the universe really ment Charlie to die, wouldn't he have smashed into those rocks in the hippy van? __________________ I miss you Kaidaa. xxx JJB Lostie - with an IE

03-23-2007, 12:41 AM	#15 (permalink)
The_abbott SHANNON'S BACK SCRUB Island Believer Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Shannon's Bikini Fave Character: Shannon Lost Item: Sonic Fence Posts: 7,590 Awards Showcase Total Awards: 3	Desmond is saving Claire, not Charlie The only way I will except Charlie dying is if he dies protecting Claire and Aaron so excepting his fate. If he dies catching a bird then thats just stupid and wasteful. I would stil rather Claire died......or Kate....or Paulo. __________________ 0 Days to I'm on 6 months LC sabbatical Shannon's 'body'guard Winner of the Joke thread battle with FBF Winner of the DINNER is the evening meal thread FACT = Kate put the "ate" in "Hate"