Is Danielle good or bad?

[misspiggy]

I don't know if I trust Danielle, what do you think?

[Mantis Zero]

I definately think theres something dodgy about her, my theory is she and her team were working for Dharma (as scientists) near the island, possibly something to do with that cable we saw Sayid find. The stories she tells I think are a mix and match of the truth and lies, she's not an Other but she's definately seen them before Henry was caught. Is this how she knew Henry was one of them? Because she's met him before and knows he isnt who he said he was?

[kirsty290182]

Am i being naive in believing that she is a victim aswell. I mean, i have no reason to doubt her, if she was one of them, then why would they take her child? Why is she always running away from them and fighting/shooting them???

[E Pluribus Unum]

I think shes a bit (crazy) but I posted somewhere else; how much have our losties ACTUALLY done - IF you take away all the visions/dreams?

They wouldn't have found -
The Pearl [and alll things associated]
The Swan [and alll things associated]
The Nigerian Plane [and alll things associated]
The Caves [and alll things associated]
Etc
Etc
Etc

I think, normally - Dani not seeing/anyone or anything would be questionable. But it would be easy to believe that 'they' showed our losties things and just kept Dani at arms length for the last 16 [ish] years..

I think she's on the losties side, just a little - well - lonely

[E Pluribus Unum]

Although I do like the idea;

She came to the island 16 years ago to work for Dharma and then her baby was kidnapped and her crew died etc

Perhaps she rebelled!

[The_abbott]

Lets face it theres no way she has been on the island for 16 years and came knows nothing about anything (well except the black rock). She has never seen a hatch or the others yet dimwits like Jack and Kate and Locke and Boone can find all these things in 40 days.

She must of seen the others at some stage. Shes lieing. I suspect she was an other at some stage but booted out for some reason.

Also why has noone bothered looking for the radio tower she mentioned long time ago!

[D-Roc]

Originally Posted by Mantis Zero,September 12, 2006 09:58 pm

I definately think theres something dodgy about her, my theory is she and her team were working for Dharma (as scientists) near the island, possibly something to do with that cable we saw Sayid find. The stories she tells I think are a mix and match of the truth and lies, she's not an Other but she's definately seen them before Henry was caught. Is this how she knew Henry was one of them? Because she's met him before and knows he isnt who he said he was?

I dont think she's met Henry before because Henry didnt seem to know who she was - "that woman"..although he couldve been lying i suppose.

I agree about Rousseau's mix of truth and lies.

[St. Anger]

in her 16 years, surely the Others would have either killed her (although not necessarily) or captured her, and she would have more stories to tell the Losties.

The Losties never seemed to ask her much did they, except how she got on the island. I bet she knows a thing or 2 about the Others. If she was sent to work for Dharma, then who kidnapped Alex? We must assume Dharma did because Alex is working for the Others. Or maybe the Others are not Dharma as many have speculated.

Mayb we have not yet seen Dharma people.

I'm suprised Dany hasn't encountered the Others and asked them about her child..............., mayb she has.

[D-Roc]

It sure is a tangled web that shes woven isnt it!

I suspect that she does know more about the others than she's letting on. Though i reckon shes telling the truth about Alex, i think they have kept her from Danielle. In fact it's almost as if they arent even bothered by Rousseau's presence/threat.

As for Dharma, i think that they are Zeke's people. Either that or they are posing as Dharma. Im starting to think that this is very possible..espcially after Walt's little revelation - "Theyre not who they say they are, theyre pretending!"

This would indeed explain the disgiuses and why they are so covert and sneaky. Im thinking that they could well be ex US Military personnel who were drafted to the island may years ago for some reason..and have ended up staying there or being trapped ther even. Though im still open to the idea that they are indeed Dharm people who have been driven underground/ousted by HF. Or maybe a mixture of both ideas..

Eitherway i do believe that there are at least 2 seperate factions of 'others' on the island.

[Nickeshi]

Have there been any signs of two groups of others, because all the ones that we've seen are from zeke's group, i thought there might have been two groups but now i'm not too sure

[St. Anger]

Originally Posted by KoRevo,September 17, 2006 12:18 pm

It sure is a tangled web that shes woven isnt it!

I suspect that she does know more about the others than she's letting on. Though i reckon shes telling the truth about Alex, i think they have kept her from Danielle. In fact it's almost as if they arent even bothered by Rousseau's presence/threat.

As for Dharma, i think that they are Zeke's people. Either that or they are posing as Dharma. Im starting to think that this is very possible..espcially after Walt's little revelation - "Theyre not who they say they are, theyre pretending!"

This would indeed explain the disgiuses and why they are so covert and sneaky. Im thinking that they could well be ex US Military personnel who were drafted to the island may years ago for some reason..and have ended up staying there or being trapped ther even. Though im still open to the idea that they are indeed Dharm people who have been driven underground/ousted by HF. Or maybe a mixture of both ideas..

Eitherway i do believe that there are at least 2 seperate factions of 'others' on the island.

I guess Zeke and Co. could be Dharma and Walt simply meant thaey are not simply genuine ragged, homeless, and stuck on the island, but they are scientists in reality.

But as for the past theories about a Dharma and Hanso conflict, I believe this could be correct.

The operation of the island is definitely not as straight forward as originally thought.

[hundredand8]

Look, shes just one single woman.

The survivors of flight 815 are about ~40.

She can remain hidden, its entirely plausible, and if she never ventures out to the north she never makes contact with The Others.

And why is this thread on E4, and not on C4? I don't see no spoilers...

[misspiggy]

sorry, I put it on here cos I was watching E4 episodes and was on auto pilot when I wondered what people thought of Danielle.

Maybe if we ask Roco nicely he'll move it over??

[hundredand8]

Originally Posted by misspiggy,September 18, 2006 07:33 pm

sorry, I put it on here cos I was watching E4 episodes and was on auto pilot when I wondered what people thought of Danielle.

Maybe if we ask Roco nicely he'll move it over??

Rocco,

me and Miss Piggy are asking you nicely to transfer this thread to C4

yours truly,

hundredand8