Jin or Charlie.....Which one was most sad?

[*SP*]

I'm bemused also. I'm not being funny but how are people making sense of it all if they think it was Jin's flashforward? They must be mighty confused.

I'm quite convinced that he is dead. I've seen loads of people doubt it, but the emotions and actions of Sun (and Hurley) seemed genuine. And much as it saddened me to learn of his death, if the writers do a turn around there it'll be shoddy. I won't be impressed.

[Aerc]

I gotta go with Charlie. He did it for Aaron and Claire. Then it looked like he was gonna make it after all but then pull out a grenade and blew open the side. He pulled the door shut saving Desmond and he wrote "Not Penny's Boat" on his hand. The last thing he did was warn the rest of them that it wasn't Penny's boat.

[Reed]

Originally Posted by *SP*

I'm bemused also. I'm not being funny but how are people making sense of it all if they think it was Jin's flashforward? They must be mighty confused. .

For me personally it was the Polar Bear. I assumed Jin was on his way to the hospital to see Sun, while bringing her a gift that was remembering of the Island. I gave the episode too much thought without realising the little clues that told us it was a flashback. I could not make sense of several issues as far as it being a flashback was concerned.

[Reed]

Originally Posted by Aerc

I gotta go with Charlie. He did it for Aaron and Claire. Then it looked like he was gonna make it after all but then pull out a grenade and blew open the side. He pulled the door shut saving Desmond and he wrote "Not Penny's Boat" on his hand. The last thing he did was warn the rest of them that it wasn't Penny's boat.

I watched Greatest Hits last night - a very sad episode and the beginning of the end for Charlie. Very sad seeing him say goodbye to everyone without them even realising. Great episode.