Nooo Claire cant die! She cant!!

[esn]

Ok from the twist at the end it seems that somthing has happened to Claire or Kate wouldnt be playing Mumma with Aarron.

I really hope that she hasnt died - shes too nice to die. And why hasnt Kate told Aarron the turth anyways - shes a complusive liar that one . Unless of course it was a dying wish of Claires. I really dont like where this is headed with that. I hope that by Kates time, somhow Claire is still on the island. Alas, we know who the the island treats mothers so Im worried they are gonna kill sweet lovely innocent pretty Claire. And the fact that Kate was allowing Aarron to call her Mommy - she wouldnt do that if Claire was still alive.

Bugger.

[IM-LOST-WITH-LOST]

Originally Posted by esn

Ok from the twist at the end it seems that somthing has happened to Claire or Kate wouldnt be playing Mumma with Aarron.

I really hope that she hasnt died - shes too nice to die. And why hasnt Kate told Aarron the turth anyways - shes a complusive liar that one . Unless of course it was a dying wish of Claires. I really dont like where this is headed with that. I hope that by Kates time, somhow Claire is still on the island. Alas, we know who the the island treats mothers so Im worried they are gonna kill sweet lovely innocent pretty Claire. And the fact that Kate was allowing Aarron to call her Mommy - she wouldnt do that if Claire was still alive.

Bugger.

I second all of that! Kate can't tell Aaron, he's like what 2? You cant tell him that his real mum is dead and that its all a big cover up, he'd obviously blab

I'm keeping positive though, I'm hoping that the frieghters take Aaron before they try and kill off the islanders. Then when Aaron is on the frieghter or somewere like that, Kate rescues him and passes her off as her own to tie in with the cover up

[monster-eats-pilot]

Unless Aaron isnt Aaron and Clarie and Aaron are ok somewhere else and this is a different Aaron and I'll shut up now

[TheDharmaShark]

You arent implying anything with that are you?

Anyway, that entire episode ending would be rendered pointless if it wasnt Claire's Aaron.

I think Claire is still on the Island with the ones who presumably remain there and the fact that Kate is claiming Aaron to be hers means that its all part of this big cover story theyve got going on.

[monster-eats-pilot]

It's Lost. Anything is possible.

[esn]

It would be unlikely MEP, since as DS says, it would make the whole ending pointless.

I can sorta buy Claire still being on the island. I just get the feeling that that isnt the case or Kate would have told him the turth - she could also have told him not to tell anybody.

I have awful visions of Kate going mad and snatching Aarron from Claires arms.

[monster-eats-pilot]

Oh you'll be sorry when I'm right I'm joking I know it's Claire's Aaron [ I think]
We're gonna have to wait ages for answers though >:|

[IM-LOST-WITH-LOST]

Originally Posted by esn

I can sorta buy Claire still being on the island. I just get the feeling that that isnt the case or Kate would have told him the turth - she could also have told him not to tell anybody.

Why do people keep saying this? Aaron looked like he was about 2... You wouldn't tell a 2 year old that your not his mother, his real mother is still alive on an island with lots of other people, but tell him to keep quite because theres a huge cover up that no one is supposed to know about. If my mum told me that now i'd slip up

[TheDharmaShark]

I agree lol

Aaron doesnt need to know that, it wouldnt do a child of his age any good, it'd just totally confuse him

[esn]

Originally Posted by IM-LOST-WITH-LOST

Why do people keep saying this? Aaron looked like he was about 2... You wouldn't tell a 2 year old that your not his mother, his real mother is still alive on an island with lots of other people, but tell him to keep quite because theres a huge cover up that no one is supposed to know about. If my mum told me that now i'd slip up

I dont know, I think that a 2 year old would get that he had to keep quite. Maybe.

[IM-LOST-WITH-LOST]

Originally Posted by esn

I dont know, I think that a 2 year old would get that he had to keep quite. Maybe.

Yeah he might understand it, but would he not slip up? Let's say the roles were reversed, would you take the chance in telling him?

[esn]

ok fair enough. But Im still gonna take it as a sign that Claires dead.

[Murgatroyd]

How does this tie in with Desmond's vision of both Claire and Aaron taking off in a helicopter?

[Andy9283]

Something must have seriously gone wrong for Desmonds 'prophesey' to not come true (Claire flying away on heli).