Ok Johns been telling 4 of the O6 to go back, so did Charlie to Hurley and Ben said they all had to go back - including a dead John
But whys Claire appearing to Kate in a dream and telling her not to take Aarron back? I mean she did seem rather forceful.
Could it be that the rest are red herrings and Claire is the one to listen too? Or is there an enemy of the island at work here and making Claire appear to Kate? Because thats all I got at the moment
