[Reed]

I think we ALL assume the Oceanic Six are going to return to the Island in the future, though how will Hurley accomplish this? I suppose everyone can have a sudden turn around in health.

What will it take for Hurley to regain his health? Hurley voluntarily went back to Santa Rosa after seeing Charlie at the Convenience Store so surely his visits from Charlie SHOULD help should they not? Or is Charlie purely screwing his mind up more - if indeed it IS Charlie.

If I were Hurley I would accept that it REALLY is Charlie and then 'somehow' manage to prove I am sane, perhaps with his help? Easier said than done, but it would have been accomplishable had Hurley's mental health not worsened as we saw in 4x10.

What made Hurley go downhill? Can he not accept that Charlie is really there? - I wonder what they have been talking about on the garden bench?