I read this when you first posted, and completely agreed, yet it just came to me that if the island won't let people die, then whoever was in the coffin mustn't adhere to the rules. As I understand it you mean that they can die as long as it's a sort of redemption thing, is that what you mean??? If not SORRY. Anyway whoever is in the coffin must have redeemed themselves so how come no one cared enough to turn up at the funeral??? Maybe we can work out who it could be with a bit of discussion and logic!!! If not we should be able to rule out the definate no no's.
This isn't a critisism of your post, far from it, but as it seems such good reasoning, it's another line of questioning that we could use with your idea.
|