View Single Post
Old 03-31-2008, 03:09 PM   #3 (permalink)
E Pluribus Unum
Movie-Lover
Island Guardian
 
E Pluribus Unum's Avatar
 

Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Twilight Zone
Fave Character: Locke
Lost Item: Rifle
Posts: 3,483
Awards Showcase
Sig of The Week: Signature of The Week Award - Issue reason: Signature of the week #31 LC Medal of Honour: Award for the call of duty to the Lost Community - Issue reason: Help with Forum Awards Forum Award 2007/08 Winner: Award winner for the LC Forum Awards 2007/08 - Issue reason: LC Forum Award Winner: Most Underrated Forumer Forum Award 2007/08 Winner: Award winner for the LC Forum Awards 2007/08 - Issue reason: LC Forum Award Winner: Best Username LC Medal of Honour: Award for the call of duty to the Lost Community - Issue reason: For helpfulness during recent technical issues 
Total Awards: 5
Default

I agree, I don't think she stole Aaron; as you say we have no logical reason to presume this: she has no past experiences of kidnapping/nor is she particularly fond of children...

However, I don't really think Kate took Aaron with the idea that she would use Aaron to aid in her case. As, well, we know she did what she could to avoid using Aaron in her case.

It's possible, I suppose, that Kate originally thought that (use Aaron to improve her standing) but - after creating a bond with Aaron - decided not to use him in the case (he's never mentioned during the trial, from what I remember, and from what I know - which is rather limited - the jury is asked only to use information and evidence in court to make a decision...)

I do think Kate is the kind of person who could do something like this, but from what we've seen I'm all but certain she didn't or at least changed her mind. Lest I'm missing something glaringly obvious!
__________________


Movie Reviews:
~ The Dark Knight 5/5
~ Gone Baby Gone 5/5
~ Indiana Jones and The Kingdom of the Crystal Skull 2.5/5
~ Iron Man 4/5
~ more
E Pluribus Unum is offline   Reply With Quote