I agree with all those above who said Charlie - hands down!!!!!!! The lead up to that scene, ie. with Desmond's flashes, just gave the whole thing such a powerful punch. Charlie was incredibly brave - I was crying from the time he jumped over the boat to go down to the sub, hmm think I reached a crucendo when he worked out the Beach Boys clue to the numbers to punch in. THEN the was the whole scene was slowed down with Desmond running to the control room was the final absolute genius touch.
Whereas Jin's (somewhat dubious) grave was just confusing... in fact I even felt angry towards him for deceiving Sun like that (new wife/married only 2 days WTF !?!?!?!?!? unless that FF was a totally different time, but the way the scene went it it seemed to me that Jin -the murderer of old- and his wicked ways was back in business!. No it's true to say I don't trust Jin, whereas Charlie was a fab bloke! *Incidentally my 2year old son is call Charlie too*)
|