[Kiowa Warrior]

Definately Charlie's.

Yes Jin's was sudden and there's no doubt that it was sad because, well, it's Jin, but I feel more upset about the fact that I didn't feel that upset about it! I think it might be because we actually saw Charlie's death as well as everything leading up to it, including the brief periods of hope that he might cheat fate and survive. But Jin's came out of nowhere, and I found it more shocking than saddening. Maybe after another viewing I'll find it sadder, since I found that with Boone's death.