Quote:
Originally Posted by E Pluribus Unum
To be fair, I considered Kate (FF) as a potential Hero. Although obviously we don't know the full story behind her aquiring of Aaron. Assuming she is raising him as part of a request or promise to Claire, yes - I would think that rather heroic, at the least noble...
She also did her best to keep Aaron out of the case - on two occasions - even though it would have aided her in court (letting her mother see him and using him as a character witness/sympathy vote.)
I realize this is in the incorrect thread. But since it was brought up...
|
..and you and ILWL are both Kate fans..see, only a Kate fan or advocate could possibly nominate her for 'hero of the week', in this week of all weeks!
It basically equates to me doing something like nominating Locke to 'hero of the week' after this episode - which I didn't, i might add.
My point was that ILWL is calling 'me' biased, yet clearly this doesn't make sense seeing as he (and you, it would appear) believe that Kate was a hero in Eggtown..Eggtown, of all episodes...I think not
I could understand you not wanting her to be villain of the week, but to suggest that she is 'heroic' is simply worse than any potential bias I am deemed to be showing. She is Aaron's mom, and..we don't know the details behind that - we can't simply 'assume' Kate is being selfless. You might also note that I didn't place Kate as a villain because of this - my reasons for placing her as villain are related to her allowing Jack to lie on the Bible for her, not accepting responsibility for her crimes, using Sawyer, Using Miles, Endangering her fellows by releasing Miles for a completly selfish reason, blaming her mom for dobbing her in (when it was her who executed her partner)..need I go on?
So, to clarify - you would agree with ILWL's claim for Kate being heroic on the mere 'assumption' that she is doing good in relation to Claire/Aaron...whilst also overlooking al of the BAD that she did in this episode - including the FF..?
..and I'm the one who's biased?
At least I didn't label Locke a 'hero', kinda thing
If i'm going to be called biased I would like for the hecklers to check themselves first..I mean,
Eggtown Kate..Hero of the week? Whaaaaaa??
Honestly EPU, ILWL deserved to rot in his own hypocrisy for this one
But as they say, it's a game of opinions..I just can't believe i'm being called biased when Kate fans are suggesting Kate was a Hero last week.
