I thought it was stunning! And that's really saying something given it was Hurley-centric (usually cue yawn) and the amount of Jack in it (to be expected though and so can be forgiven). It could really have gone either way, in that the anticipation from waiting so long for it could have resulted in a huge anti-climax...but quite the opposite. It did have quite a different feel to it from the other 3 seasons...that could have been due to the flashforward as oppose flashbacks we're used to, but I felt it was just more...intense...or something. Nice dark feel to it, while at the same time throwing up a few more juicy questions.
I loved it, so I did! I'll say an 8, the optimist in me is holding back from going higher and hoping I'll need the 9s and 10s in due course.
