Quote:
|
Originally Posted by *SP*,March 29, 2007 09:04 pm
Exactly. I mean, in order to find someone guilty don't you have to eliminate all reasonable doubt. Really we don't know what happened. Ethan could have knocked Charlie out in order to get away with Claire and anyone could have come along and thought 'what a fantastic little opportunity to get shot of the annoying little english twerp'. That person could have hung Charlie and poor Ethan is getting all the blame. Now, I'm not saying that's what happened...but it could have. There's enough reasonable doubt there to get Ethan aquitted for sure.  |
LOL I'd bet half the island would like to have done away with that annoying little twerp! I do think that Ethan either hung Charlie himself or instructed someone else to do so, but even still I don't know why he should be punished for such a thing!